[Download] "Santa Barbara Pistachio Ranch V. Chowchilla Water Dist." by California Court of Appeals ~ eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free

eBook details

Title: Santa Barbara Pistachio Ranch V. Chowchilla Water Dist.
Author : California Court of Appeals
Release Date : January 11, 2001
Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
Pages : * pages
Size : 80 KB

Description

Santa Barbara Pistachio Ranch and Maple Leaf Pistachio Ranch (plaintiffs) filed suit against Chowchilla Water District (the District), alleging irrigation water provided by the District resulted in the death of several of their mature pistachio trees. At trial, the court ruled the proper measure of damages was the diminution in the value of plaintiffs' land and the cost of restoring the trees, but not the lost profits that could have been derived from the diseased trees. Conceding their damages were de minimis under the court's ruling, plaintiffs made an offer of proof and requested that non-suit be entered against them. On appeal, plaintiffs contend that our holding in Serian Brothers, Inc. v. Agri-Sun Nursery (1994) 25 Cal.App.4th 306, applies to claims for damages to permanent crops arising under trespass and nuisance theories of liability and that the proper measure of their damages includes lost future profits. We find Serian Brothers is not controlling here, since it did not directly address the issue of lost profits based on tort theories of liability. However, we conclude the court erred in granting non-suit, as lost profits may potentially be considered in determining the applicable costs of restoring the pistachio groves.